Another tough call today, similar to the tough call on wheat 5/27/20 (
https://jmstweets.blogspot.com/2020/05/july-wheat-got-in-my-face-update-3.html).
The 4 days consisting of today and the last 3 trading days form a sell signal. Its a kind of double doji Evening Star candle pattern.
Today and yesterday's 2 candles form a sell signal also. Its a "doji gap down".
And today's candle alone is a red candle with no top wick that closed below the 8ema.
All 3 of these bearish signals are telling me to close our long position. However, I see extenuating circumstances.
We are oscillating up and down within a fairly well defined consolidation range between 857 1/2 and 828 1/2. So it seems likely if we do continue down we'll probably stop and reverse at the bottom of that range. The 4/21/20 candle does have a scary low at 818 1/2, but that looks anomalous compared to the other candles.
Here's an analogy. Look at the 3 candles from 5/21/20 - 5/26/20. They make a strong bullish pattern. Its described in an earlier post in this thread. But does it rocket upward, as you'd expect? No, price is stifled at the 34ema and 50sma resistance area, forms doji's and gaps down today with continuation. I point this out because we just had a strong buy signal fail within this consolidation. So if today's sell signal also fails at the bottom of the consolidation, it wouldn't be very surprising.
Also, notice our low today, and yesterday for that matter, stops exactly on a downward Trend Line. Its not uncommon to retest a level after a break out. The 5/26/20 candle can be considered a break out through the Trend Line. So maybe we're just retesting the Trend Line after the break out.
I've given 2 reasons not to exit. Here's another one. July Corn, Soy Oil, and Wheat all look bullish. Soy Meal's decline has leveled out on very low stochastics, so that doesn't look very threatening. These other grain futures provide a somewhat supportive price environment for Soybeans.
Do we sell, as our trading rules instruct, or do we hold due to the specific circumstances of this trade? The rules assume we can always buy back in, but we could gap up when the market re-opens Sunday night, and run up much higher before I can wake up and do something about it. I could enter a conditional order to enter if price exceeds a a certain level, but we could have a large gap up followed by a big profit taking down move. I'd much rather deal with a market re-open in real time where I can use my judgement.
Today's candle closed close to halfway back up and close to the 8ema, although this is a very weak argument to not sell.
Due to the very muted reaction to buy and sell signals earlier in this consolidation since 4/22/20, and the fact that today is a Friday, I decided to hold our long position.
However, since the bottom of the consolidation is 828 1/2, I changed our Stop Loss from 830 to 827 1/2.